HyreRemodel
Plan Your Remodel

Before you hire

Choosing a remodeling contractor

The contractor you choose matters more than any material you specify, and the selection is usually made on the weakest evidence in the whole project: a conversation, a number, and a feeling. This page sets out a process that produces better evidence: how to build a shortlist, what to verify and where, how to make three proposals genuinely comparable, and what the answers tell you.

Last updated .

HyreRemodel does not vet, rate or recommend contractors. We have no verification programme and no rating system, and we do not describe any company as trusted. This page exists so you can do the checking yourself, with the same rigour a verification programme would claim. What we actually do is written out plainly, including what we do not.

Do this before you contact anyone

Most bad hiring decisions are made earlier than people think, not at the moment of choosing, but at the moment of asking, when the project was too vaguely defined for the answers to mean anything.

  • Write the scope down, room by room: what stays, what goes, what is installed. Every item left undefined becomes a decision made later under time pressure at a higher price.
  • Establish what is structural, or at least flag where you suspect it. This determines whether you need drawings before you need bids.
  • Decide whether you need a designer first. If the layout changes, drawings usually come before pricing. See design-build vs hiring an architect.
  • Set allowances or make selections, so that proposals are pricing the same fixtures rather than each company’s assumption.
  • Separate needs from wants, in writing. This is what you will negotiate against later, and it is far easier to write now.
  • Set a contingency, held outside whatever you tell contractors your budget is.

Building the shortlist

The sources that reliably produce better candidates than an internet search, roughly in order:

  • People who have had comparable work done. Comparable in type and scale, not merely "a remodel". A superb bathroom contractor may be the wrong firm for a structural addition.
  • Trades and suppliers you already trust. Electricians, plumbers and lumber yards know who pays on time and who they will not work under, which is unusually good signal.
  • Your building department. Inspectors will not recommend, but they see everyone’s work and the questions you can ask are still useful.
  • Architects and designers, if you are using one, since they bid work regularly and have watched contractors execute their drawings.
  • State licensing board records, where a licence exists, to check standing and complaint history before you invest any time.

Weight recency and relevance. A company that did excellent work five years ago may have different people now, and the individual who will actually run your job matters more than the company name on the truck.

Verify before you invest time

Verification takes an afternoon and removes candidates before you have spent weeks on them.

CheckHow, and what it tells you
Licence or registrationDirectly with the issuing board, using the official lookup rather than a number on a business card. Confirms standing, classification and complaint history where published. Note that requirements differ enormously by state.
Trade licences underneathElectrical and plumbing are separately licensed in most states even where general contracting is not. Verify the trades individually.
General liability insuranceCertificate sent by the insurer or broker directly. Covers damage to your property and injury to third parties. Check the dates cover the whole project.
Workers' compensationA separate policy covering the contractor’s employees. Matters to you because without it an injured worker may have a claim against the homeowner.
Business identityA verifiable physical address, a business entity registered with the state, and a history that matches what you were told. A company that reformed under a new name recently is worth asking about.
Legal and complaint historyCourt records in your county and the state board’s disciplinary record. A single dispute proves little; a pattern is a pattern.
EPA lead certificationIf the house predates 1978 and the work will disturb paint, the firm generally needs to be certified under the Lead RRP Rule. Ask to see it.
References, including older onesAt least one project completed a year or more ago. Workmanship problems surface with time; a reference list of last month’s jobs cannot tell you about durability.

Where your state does not license residential general contractors at all, the verification burden shifts to you rather than disappearing. Our licence lookup directory lists the official board URLs we were able to confirm, and states without contractor licensing explains where the gap is.

Bid the same project, or do not bother bidding

Handing every company an identical package is what determines whether comparison is meaningful, and it is the step most often skipped. Give each of them:

  • The same drawings or written scope, identified by version and date.
  • The same allowances, stated as amounts.
  • The same list of what you expect to be excluded, so exclusions are visible rather than assumed.
  • The same questions, asked in writing, so the answers can be laid side by side.
  • The same deadline, and the same request for a line-item breakdown rather than a single number.

Then compare line by line. The quote comparison worksheet is built for this, and the differences it surfaces are usually in what is excluded rather than in margin.

Questions worth asking, and what the answers reveal

AskWhat you are listening for
Who will be on site day to day, and who is my point of contact?Whether there is a named person, and whether the person selling the job is the person running it.
How many projects will you have running at once?Whether your job gets continuous attention or crews that appear and disappear.
Are the trades employees or subcontractors, and are they the same people each time?Consistency, and whether workers' compensation actually covers whoever is in your house.
What have you found on projects like this that was not in the original scope?Experience. A contractor who has genuinely done this work has specific answers; a vague one may not have.
How do you price change orders, and who signs them?Whether there is a process at all, which is the difference between a disagreement and a dispute.
What are you assuming that might not be true?The single most useful question on the list. It invites honesty and it surfaces the gaps between proposals.
Who pulls the permit?It should be them. An evasive answer here is itself an answer.
What is your workmanship warranty, and how do I make a claim on it?Whether there is a process, or only a promise.
What would make you walk away from this project?Judgement, and whether they are being straight with you about risk.

The profile to walk away from

Home improvement fraud takes a consistent shape, documented by the Federal Trade Commission and recognisable everywhere. Any single item can have an innocent explanation; several together are the pattern:

  • An unsolicited approach, door to door or shortly after storm damage in the neighbourhood.
  • Pressure to sign immediately, or a price available only today.
  • A demand for a large share of the money up front, particularly in cash.
  • No written contract, or a contract with blanks to be filled in later.
  • No verifiable physical address, or a phone number that is the only means of contact.
  • Reluctance to pull the permit, or a request that you pull it in your own name.
  • Refusal or inability to provide insurance certificates from the insurer.
  • A price far below the others with no explanation when asked directly.
  • A recommendation to skip the permit "to save money", which transfers the entire risk to you.

After you choose

The selection is not finished when you pick a company. What protects the project from here is the contract. See contracts, payments and change orders for the clauses that matter, the payment structure to insist on, and the change order discipline that prevents most remodeling disputes before they start.

If you would rather be introduced to companies than approach them cold, tell us about the project. What we check before any introduction is made, and the things we will not do to increase volume, is published on our lead quality standard, and the FAQ covers the rest.

HyreRemodel is an independent remodeling resource and connection platform, not a remodeling contractor. We do not rate, review, endorse, recommend or vet contractors, and nothing on this page should be read as an endorsement of any company. Licensing, insurance and registration requirements are set by state and local law and vary substantially; verify current requirements with your state board and your building department.

Questions

How many contractors should I get proposals from?
Three is the usual advice and it is reasonable, but the number matters far less than whether they are pricing the same project. Three proposals developed from three different understandings of the job are three prices for three different projects, and the cheapest of them is usually the one that understood the least. If you can only get two companies to bid on identical drawings with identical allowances, that is more useful than five priced off a conversation. Spend the effort on the scope document rather than on the count.
Does a licence mean the contractor is good?
No, and it does not always mean what people assume either. A licence generally establishes that someone met a state’s minimum requirements, which may mean an examination and proof of insurance and a bond, or may mean a registration and a fee. It is a floor, not a recommendation, and it says nothing about the quality of the work or how the company behaves when something goes wrong. It is still worth verifying, because the absence of one where the state requires it tells you a great deal. What it cannot do is substitute for references, a clear contract and your own judgement.
What if my state does not license remodeling contractors?
Several do not, and Texas is the clearest example: it issues no residential general contractor licence at all, leaving requirements to municipal registration and to the separately licensed trades such as electrical and plumbing underneath. In that situation the verification burden shifts to you: check municipal registration where it exists, verify the individual trade licences that do exist, confirm insurance directly with the insurer, check court records and complaint history, and weight references and completed work more heavily. Our review of states without contractor licensing and of what "licensed contractor" actually means sets out what we were able to confirm from the boards themselves, and the licence lookup directory lists the official verification URLs.
How do I actually verify insurance?
Ask for a certificate of insurance sent to you directly by the insurer or the broker, rather than a copy handed over by the contractor, and check that the policy dates cover your whole project rather than expiring partway through. You want two things: general liability, which covers damage to your property and injury to third parties, and workers' compensation, which covers the contractor’s employees. They are different instruments and neither substitutes for the other — workers' compensation matters to you because in its absence an injured worker may have a claim against the homeowner. A licence bond, where one exists, is a third thing again and is usually far smaller than people assume. Our review of insurance requirements explains the distinctions.
What should I ask a reference?
Ask about the parts of the project that went wrong, because every project has some. "Were you happy?" produces nothing; "What was the biggest surprise, and how did they handle it?" produces the information you need. Other questions that work: was the final price close to the contract price, and if not why; how were change orders handled; did they finish, or did the last ten per cent drag; who was actually on site and did that stay consistent; was the site left safe and clean; and, the most revealing of all, would you use them again for something larger. Ask for a reference from a project completed a year or two ago as well as a recent one, because workmanship problems surface with time.
Is the lowest bid ever the right choice?
Sometimes, and you should find out why it is lowest before deciding. Legitimate reasons exist: lower overhead, a gap in the schedule, an established relationship with a particular supplier or trade. The common illegitimate reasons are all scope — something excluded, an allowance set optimistically low, or the repair work that demolition will certainly require left unpriced. The pattern to watch for is the low bid that becomes the highest final cost through change orders, which is frequent enough to be predictable. Ask the low bidder directly what they have assumed that the others may not have; the quality of that answer is itself informative.
Should I hire a designer or a design-build firm?
It depends mainly on how much the project changes and how much independent oversight you want. A separate designer or architect produces drawings that multiple contractors bid against, which gives genuine price comparison and an advocate who is not also the builder — at the cost of a separate fee and a longer front end. A design-build firm carries design and construction under one contract, which is faster and reduces the gap where design intent gets lost, at the cost of losing the competitive bid and the independent check. Both are legitimate for different projects. See design-build vs hiring an architect.
What are the warning signs of a contractor to avoid?
The Federal Trade Commission documents a consistent profile for home improvement fraud and it takes the same shape everywhere: an unsolicited approach, particularly door-to-door or after a storm; pressure to decide immediately or a price that expires today; a demand for a large share of the money up front, especially in cash; no written contract, or one with blanks in it; no verifiable business address; reluctance to pull the permit, or a request that you pull it in your name; a refusal to provide insurance certificates; and an unusually low price with no explanation for it. Any one of these can have an innocent explanation. Several together do not.
Does HyreRemodel vet, verify or recommend contractors?
No. We do not rate, review, endorse, recommend or vet remodeling contractors, and we do not describe any company as trusted. We have no verification programme, no rating system and no inspection process, and we would rather say so plainly than imply a diligence we have not done. What we publish is research sourced to state licensing boards and federal agencies, tools that show their workings, and guidance like this page on how to do the checking yourself. See how we vet for exactly what we do and do not do, written without euphemism.
When should I walk away from a contractor I have already engaged?
Before money or work is significantly ahead of where you want it to be, which means paying attention early. Concrete warning signs during a project: work starting without the permit that was promised, subcontractors mentioning they have not been paid, requests for payment out of sequence with the schedule, change orders presented after the work is done, an inability to say who will be on site tomorrow, and repeated unexplained absence. None of these are automatically fatal, but each should produce a direct conversation and a written answer. The contract’s termination and cure clauses determine what you can actually do, which is one reason to read them before signing rather than at the point you need them.

Back to the homepage