HyreRemodel
Plan Your Remodel

When a job goes wrong

Change Order Dispute: What to Do Next

A change order dispute is usually settled by the contract: what it says about how changes are priced, who may approve them and whether they must be signed first.

Read that clause, gather every written record of the change, and put your position to the contractor in writing. If that fails, your state contractor board and attorney general take complaints. This is general information, not legal advice.

Last updated

What are your rights in a change order dispute?

Your rights in a change order dispute come from two places: the contract you signed and your state’s home improvement law. A well-written contract says a change is priced and signed before the work goes ahead.

If yours says that, an unsigned extra is weaker ground for the contractor. If your contract is silent, state law and the facts decide, and that is where a lawyer in your state earns the fee.

The FTC, “How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam” (retrieved October 22, 2026) tells homeowners to try to resolve a problem with the contractor first, and to confirm phone conversations in a letter sent by certified mail with a return receipt. See remodeling contracts for what a change order should state.

Which documents should you gather?

A change order dispute is won on paper. Collect these before you call anyone:

  • The signed contract, drawings and specifications, with their dates.
  • Every change order, signed or not, and any priced proposal for the change.
  • Texts and emails where the change was discussed or approved.
  • Invoices, receipts and the payment record, showing what you paid and when.
  • Dated photos of the work before and after the change.
  • Any allowance line the change drew on.

Who should you contact?

The contractor comes first, in writing. Set out what you agreed, what you were billed and what you will pay now. If that fails:

  1. Your state contractor board. Where the state licenses the trade, the board takes complaints. Find it in our license lookup directory.
  2. Your state attorney general or local consumer protection office. The FTC names both. NAAG’s Find My AG lists every state’s office.
  3. A lawyer licensed in your state. Before you withhold a large payment, and before any lien deadline.

The building department (see permits and approvals) is only involved if the change affected permitted work. Then the permit may need an update, whoever pays.

How do you get the job finished?

Getting the job finished usually means agreeing the disputed amount separately from the rest of the work.

Ask the contractor to sign a written note that sets the disputed sum aside and lets the remaining work continue. Keep paying for finished, undisputed stages.

If the relationship has ended, the contract’s termination clause sets how work in place is valued before a new contractor starts.

The contingency calculator helps size room for future changes.

Plan the rest of the job. HyreRemodel does not do remodeling work or give legal advice. Plan Your Remodel: tell us what is left to do, and a person reads it and replies.

Questions people ask

Do I have to pay for a change I never signed?
That depends on your contract and your state’s law. Many contracts say changes must be in writing and signed before work starts. Read that clause first, and if the sum matters, ask a lawyer licensed in your state. This is general information, not legal advice.
Can the contractor stop work during a change order dispute?
Some contracts allow it after written notice, and some do not. Check the termination, cure period and dispute clauses. Stopping payment or work without following the contract can put either side in breach.
Who do I complain to about a contractor?
Your state contractor licensing board, if your state licenses the trade, and your state attorney general or local consumer protection office. The FTC names both. Our license lookup directory links each state board.
Is a text message a valid change order?
A text can be evidence that a change was agreed, but it may not meet what your contract or state law requires for a change order. Confirm it in a signed document before more work goes ahead.

Related